Apaya vs Metricool: Full Comparison
Metricool made its name with powerful analytics at accessible prices. Apaya made its name with AI that creates content for you. Our Apaya vs Metricool comparison covers how analytics-focused scheduling compares to autonomous content creation.
Quick Verdict: Metricool offers exceptional analytics and competitive tracking at budget-friendly prices—great for data-driven marketers who create their own content. Apaya offers AI content creation that eliminates the creation step. Choose Metricool if analytics drive your strategy and you have content creators. Choose Apaya if you want content handled automatically.
Comparison at a Glance
| Feature | Metricool | Apaya |
|---|---|---|
| Content Creation | ❌ Manual | ✅ AI-generated |
| Analytics Depth | ✅ Excellent | ✅ Good + AI insights |
| Competitor Analysis | ✅ Strong | ⚠️ Basic |
| Graphic Design | ⚠️ Basic editor | ✅ Branded templates |
| Scheduling | ✅ Yes | ✅ AI-optimized |
| Best Time Suggestions | ✅ Data-driven | ✅ AI-driven |
| Link in Bio | ✅ SmartLinks | ⚠️ Not included |
| Ad Analytics | ✅ Google & Meta Ads | ❌ No |
| Price Point | ✅ Very affordable | ⚠️ Higher |
| Time Investment | 5-15 hours/week | 30 minutes/week |
Pricing Comparison
Metricool Pricing
| Plan | Monthly Cost | Brands | Social Profiles | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 1 | 5 | Basic analytics, limited scheduling |
| Starter | $22/mo | 5 | 25 | Full analytics, unlimited scheduling |
| Advanced | $54/mo | 10 | 50 | Competitor analysis, reports |
| Enterprise | Custom | 25+ | 125+ | White-label, API access |
Notable: Metricool is aggressively priced. Very competitive for scheduling + analytics.
Additional costs: Content creation time, design tools, stock photos. The time investment is the hidden cost.
Apaya Pricing
| Plan | Monthly Cost | Brands | Social Accounts | What’s Included |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starter | $39/mo | 1 | 2 | Full AI automation |
| Growth | $79/mo | 1 | 4 | Full AI automation |
| Agency | $415/mo | 10 | All | Multi-brand management |
| Enterprise | $832/mo | 25 | All | Priority support |
All-inclusive: AI content creation, branded graphics, scheduling, analytics.
True Cost Analysis
| Factor | Metricool | Apaya |
|---|---|---|
| Tool cost (10 brands) | $54/mo | $415/mo |
| Content creation time | 50-100 hrs/mo | 5 hrs/mo |
| Time value @ $50/hr | $2,500-5,000/mo | $250/mo |
| True monthly cost | $2,554-5,054/mo | $665/mo |
Metricool’s tool is cheaper. The time isn’t.
Feature Breakdown
Analytics & Reporting
Metricool: This is where Metricool shines. Comprehensive analytics across all platforms, competitor benchmarking, custom reports, and historical data tracking. Ad performance tracking for Google and Meta.
Apaya: Solid analytics with AI-powered insights that automatically inform content strategy. Less depth than Metricool, but analytics drive the AI—not just dashboards.
Winner: Metricool for analytics depth, Apaya for automated action on insights.
Content Creation
Metricool: No AI content generation. You create every post yourself. Metricool organizes, schedules, and analyzes—but creation is your responsibility.
Apaya: AI generates complete posts—captions, hashtags, and branded graphics—based on your website and brand voice. 30-100+ original posts monthly.
Winner: Apaya. Metricool assumes you have content; Apaya creates it.
Competitor Analysis
Metricool: Strong competitor tracking. Monitor competitor posting frequency, engagement rates, and top content. Benchmark your performance against theirs.
Apaya: Basic competitive awareness through Social Scanner. More focused on lead opportunities than competitive benchmarking.
Winner: Metricool for competitive intelligence.
Scheduling & Publishing
Metricool: Full scheduling with best time recommendations based on your historical data. Auto-posting across platforms with queue management.
Apaya: AI-optimized scheduling that learns optimal times for your specific audience. Automatically adapts based on engagement patterns.
Winner: Tie—both solid, different approaches.
Link in Bio
Metricool: SmartLinks feature creates Instagram-style link pages. Track clicks and conversions from bio traffic.
Apaya: No built-in link-in-bio feature. You’d use a separate tool like Linktree.
Winner: Metricool for this specific feature.
Ads Tracking
Metricool: Track Google Ads and Meta Ads performance alongside organic social. Unified view of paid and organic efforts.
Apaya: No ads tracking. Focused on organic social media automation.
Winner: Metricool for paid media visibility.
Pros and Cons
Metricool Pros
- ✅ Exceptional analytics at low cost
- ✅ Strong competitor tracking
- ✅ Google & Meta Ads integration
- ✅ SmartLinks (link in bio)
- ✅ Very affordable pricing
- ✅ Generous free tier
Metricool Cons
- ❌ No content creation—you do all the work
- ❌ Basic design tools
- ❌ Time investment remains high
- ❌ Great at measuring, doesn’t help with creating
- ❌ Analytics don’t write posts for you
Apaya Pros
- ✅ AI creates all content automatically
- ✅ Branded graphics included
- ✅ Minimal time investment
- ✅ Analytics drive AI improvement
- ✅ Simple setup and workflow
- ✅ Scales without proportional time
Apaya Cons
- ❌ Less analytics depth
- ❌ No competitor tracking
- ❌ No ads integration
- ❌ No link-in-bio feature
- ❌ Higher base price
Who Should Choose Metricool
Metricool is ideal for:
- Analytics-driven marketers who make decisions based on data
- Budget-conscious users who need powerful features at low cost
- Teams that create content and need measurement
- Paid + organic managers needing unified analytics
- Competitive strategists who benchmark against competitors
You’ll love Metricool if: You’re data-driven, enjoy creating content, and want affordable analytics that rival enterprise tools. The creation is fun for you; you need better measurement.
Who Should Choose Apaya
Apaya is ideal for:
- Time-constrained professionals who can’t create content
- Businesses where analytics are nice but content is the bottleneck
- Anyone whose current problem is “I don’t post enough”
- Teams that would rather approve than create
- Brands that want consistent presence without the work
You’ll love Apaya if: You know analytics matter, but you can’t analyze posts you never created. Getting content out is the first problem to solve.
The Analytics vs. Automation Question
This comparison highlights different priorities:
The Data-First Approach (Metricool)
- Create content
- Schedule and publish
- Analyze performance
- Refine strategy based on data
- Create more content (manually)
Requirement: You have time and ability to create content.
The Automation-First Approach (Apaya)
- AI creates content
- AI schedules based on engagement data
- You review and approve
- AI learns and improves automatically
- Cycle continues
Requirement: You have 30 minutes per week.
If you’re already creating great content, Metricool helps you measure it.
If you’re not creating enough content, Apaya solves that first.
Migration: Switching from Metricool to Apaya
If you’re considering the switch:
- Keep Metricool for analytics if you want—you can run both
- Connect your website to Apaya for brand learning
- Compare AI output to your historical best performers
- Let Apaya handle creation while using Metricool for deeper analytics
- Transition fully once you’re confident in AI output
Some users keep Metricool for competitive tracking while Apaya handles content.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use both Metricool and Apaya?
Yes. Some users let Apaya create content while using Metricool for competitive analysis and deeper analytics. It’s redundant for scheduling but complementary for insights.
Metricool is so much cheaper—why pay more for Apaya?
Metricool’s tool cost is lower. But the time cost of content creation isn’t included. Calculate your hourly rate times hours spent creating content, then compare total cost.
What about Metricool’s AI features?
Metricool has added some AI caption assistance, but it’s supplementary—you still drive content creation. Apaya’s AI is the core product, creating complete posts autonomously.
Will I miss Metricool’s analytics?
Apaya has solid analytics that inform the AI. If you need competitor tracking or ads integration specifically, you might miss those features. Consider whether those drive decisions you actually make.
Which is better for small businesses?
Depends on your constraint. If you have time to create content and want affordable analytics, Metricool. If you don’t have time to create content, Apaya—regardless of analytics depth.
Making the Call
Metricool is right for data-driven marketers who create content and need powerful, affordable analytics with competitor tracking.
Apaya is right for anyone whose primary challenge is content creation—where analytics matter but only if you have content to analyze.
| Your Priority | Choose |
|---|---|
| Deep analytics | Metricool |
| Competitor tracking | Metricool |
| Ads integration | Metricool |
| Budget constraints | Metricool |
| AI content creation | Apaya |
| Time savings | Apaya |
| Consistent posting | Apaya |
| Hands-off automation | Apaya |
Ready to Try Apaya?
See what AI automation does for your content.
Start Your Free Trial → | View Pricing →
No credit card required • Live in 5 minutes • Cancel anytime
More Comparisons
Researching other tools? See how Apaya compares:
- Apaya vs Hootsuite — The original scheduler vs AI automation
- Apaya vs Buffer — Simple queues vs AI content creation
- Apaya vs Later — Visual planning vs AI automation
- Apaya vs SocialBee — Category scheduling vs AI generation
Related Resources
- AI Social Media Automation: Complete Guide — How AI automation actually works
- ROI of AI Social Media Automation — Calculate your potential savings
- All Comparisons — View all tool comparisons